2021 BSL Hall of Fame Results

[cjay101]

The eligibility threshold was adjusted as follows
Career Innings Pitched: 2000 from 1750

BOLD ARE 1st year eligibles

2021 BSL Hall of Fame Ballot

- Players Have 15 years to get voted in, then they are ineligible
- 75% must be reached for Induction
(Anyone obtaining under 10% of the ballot will fall off)

Hitters

(Must have 5000+ Career AB to be eligible for ballot)

Albert Pujols - 47% (3rd year)
Keith Nelson - 40% (2nd year)
Elmer Williams - 37% (1st year)
Manny Reynad - 35% (1st year)
Dane Keogh - 34% (11th year)
Josh Hamilton - 34% (2nd year)
Dan Nelson - 34% (4th year)
John Herbert - 33% (8th year)
Scott Moore - 33% (2nd year)
Cody Ross - 33% (10th year)
Raul Clemente - 32% (10th year)
Kenny Lofton - 31% (8th year)
Mark Teixeira - 31% (3rd year)
Juan Cordova - 31% (6th year)
Jeremy Cunningham - 30% (11th year)
John McCauley - 30% (3rd year)
Augusto Linchinchi - 29% (3rd year)
Bobby Abreu - 27% (8th year)
Troy Glaus - 27% (11th year)
Lance Berkman - 26% (8th year)
Jermaine Dye - 26% (8th year)
Kelly Johnson - 25% (4th year)
Aramis Ramirez - 24% (6th year)
Joey Votto - 24% (3rd year)
Arnie Wright - 24% (2nd year)
Miguel Durango - 22% (1st year)
Jacoby Ellsbury 22% (5th year)
Pablo Sandoval - 22% (1st year)
Jed Lowrie - 20% (1st year)
Jorge Posada - 19% (11th year)
Carlos Gonzalez - 19% (2nd year)
Miguel Cabrera - 18% (1st year)
Justin Morneau - 16% (4th year)
David Murphy - 13% (3rd year)
Augusto Ramirez - 11% (2nd year)

Denard Span - fell off
Jay Bruce - fell off
Jason Hayes - fell off
JJ Hardy - fell off
Jose B Reyes - fell off
Russell Branyan - fell off
Alexis Rios - fell off
Yadier Molina - fell off
Carlos Lee - fell off
Juan Pierre - fell off
Casey McGehee - fell off



Starting Pitcher (Must have 2000 IP to be eligible for ballot)

Brandon Webb - 45% (2nd year)
Bob Jefferson - 37% (2nd year)
CC Sabathia - 36% (1st year)
Roy Oswalt - 35% (8th year)
Cliff Lee - 34% (8th year)
John Higgins - 34% (6th year)
Randy Johnson - 31% (12th year)
Tim Hudson - 30% (11th Year)
Kelvim Escobar 30% (5th year)
Dan Reed - 30% (1st year)
Justin Denton - 29% (2nd year)
Rich Harden - 28% (3rd year)
Juan Melendez - 27% (7th year)
Matt Cain - 27% (2nd year)
Hiroki Kuroda - 25% (9th year)
Wandy Rodriguez - 25% (8th year)
Jose Perez - 25% (3rd year)
Ben Sheets 25% (5th year)
Jake Westbrook - 21% (10th year)
Andy Sonnanstine - 19% (3rd year)
Cole Hamels - 19% (2nd year)
Scott T Baker - 18% (2nd year)
Mike Mussina - 17% (8th year)
Erik Bedard 17% (5th year)
Jake Peavy - 15% (4th year)
Dan Haren - 12% (2nd year)
Jeremy Bonderman - 10% (1st year)


Ervin Santana - fell off
James Shields - fell off
Zach Greinke - fell off
Fernando Escobar - fell off
Jered Weaver - fell off
Carlos Zambrano - fell off
Bronson Arroyo - fell off
Roy Halladay - fell off
Bruce Lamb - fell off
Alberto De Los Santos - fell off
Myeong-hwan Kim - fell off
Dana Eveland - fell off
Juan Rodriguez - fell off
Chris Capuano - fell off
Brett Myers - fell off



Relief Pitcher (Must have 150 Saves to be eligible)

Parker Arnold - 36% (1st year)
Joba Chamberlain - 31% (8th year)
Steve Kelly - 30% (6th year)
Francisco Rodriguez - 17% (2nd year)
Gilberto Paz - 17% (1st year)

Sergio Romo - fell off
Jay Baker - fell off
Ken Allen - fell off
Rod Sampson - fell off
Matt Capps - fell off

 

[tglg]

Never figured that Ervin Santana would get in, but wanted to see what he got in his first season.....must say a bit shocked that he didn't even get 10%. Given that when I compare him to Webb, who has the most of any pitcher, I find these comparisions -

Games - Webb 443 Santana 435
Wins - Webb 176 Santana 169
IP - Webb 2673 Santana 2719
K's - Webb 1819 Santana 2225
WHIP - Webb 1.21 Santana 1.22
ERA - Webb 3.43 Santana 3.82

Highlights
Webb - 1 World Series title, 1 Cy Young, 5 time All-Star
Santana - 3 World Series titles

So it looks like some of those individual highlights must weigh a bit. I also noticed that VORP was a pretty wide spread Webb - 556.4 vs Santana 399.7. A bit shocked at that spread as well, given who similar their career numbers are.

Even Jeremy Bonderman got 10%, and his career numbers were 470 games, a record of 155-154, 2794 IP, 2150 Ks, 1.36 WHIP, and a 4.42 ERA. Wonder what the slight was for Santana. Did I maybe convert him to a MR at the end of this injury plagued season, and thus caused him to miss some threshold? He never pitched this year.

 

[cjay101]

Never figured that Ervin Santana would get in, but wanted to see what he got in his first season.....must say a bit shocked that he didn't even get 10%. Given that when I compare him to Webb, who has the most of any pitcher, I find these comparisions -

Games - Webb 443 Santana 435
Wins - Webb 176 Santana 169
IP - Webb 2673 Santana 2719
K's - Webb 1819 Santana 2225
WHIP - Webb 1.21 Santana 1.22
ERA - Webb 3.43 Santana 3.82

Highlights
Webb - 1 World Series title, 1 Cy Young, 5 time All-Star
Santana - 3 World Series titles

So it looks like some of those individual highlights must weigh a bit. I also noticed that VORP was a pretty wide spread Webb - 556.4 vs Santana 399.7. A bit shocked at that spread as well, given who similar their career numbers are.

Even Jeremy Bonderman got 10%, and his career numbers were 470 games, a record of 155-154, 2794 IP, 2150 Ks, 1.36 WHIP, and a 4.42 ERA. Wonder what the slight was for Santana. Did I maybe convert him to a MR at the end of this injury plagued season, and thus caused him to miss some threshold? He never pitched this year.

I think he had 8 or 9% on the calculations. There are a lot of solid players that were for the most part average from season to season, so without those huge stick-out numbers, found it hard to compete. You can make the same argument for about 3 or 4 SP's that didn't make the cut over the years.

 

[Meliah]

Go Keogh

 

[spartanfan1]

I'm a little surprised SP Dan Reed retired. I thought he might have one more decent year left - I was actually thinking of making him an offer this SIM, but I guess that won't happen now, lol!

Eric