Want list: NFL HOF Rookie Cards

[cjay101]

Below is what I still NEED. Some are really easy, some are really hard to find. Regarding vintage, I'm not looking for PSA 9's. I'm looking for a reasonably appealing card. A bit off center or scratch and ding is fine with me, I can upgrade later on, especially the high end stuff. Post 1980, looking for NM/MT.

Please let me know if you have any of these, and what you would want in return. I will consider buying if you're pricing to sell.



Larry Allen - 1994 Stadium Club #288 Larry Allen RC
Lance Alworth - 1963 Fleer #72 Lance Alworth RC
Doug Atkins - 1954 Bowman #4 Doug Atkins RC
Sammy Baugh - 1948 Bowman #22 Sammy Baugh RC
Bobby Beathard
Chuck Bednarik - 1948 Leaf #54A Chuck Bednarik YB RC/(Yellow background)
Raymond Berry - 1957 Topps #94 Raymond Berry RC
Fred Biletnikoff - 1965 Topps #133 Fred Biletnikoff SP RC
Terry Bradshaw - 1971 Topps #156 Terry Bradshaw RC
Robert Brazile
Jim Brown - 1958 Topps #62 Jim Brown RC
Paul Brown - 1952 Bowman Large #14 Paul Brown CO RC
Willie Brown - 1965 Topps #46 Willie Brown SP RC
Nick Buoniconti - 1963 Fleer #10 Nick Buoniconti RC
Dick Butkus - 1966 Philadelphia #31 Dick Butkus RC
Tony Canadeo - 1950 Bowman #9 Tony Canadeo RC
Jack Christiansen - 1952 Bowman Small #129 Jack Christiansen RC
George Connor - 1948 Leaf #37B George Connor RC/(dark yellow pants)
Lou Creekmur - 1949 Topps Felt Backs #19 Lou Creekmur RC
Brian Dawkins
Len Dawson - 1963 Fleer #47 Len Dawson RC
Edward DeBartolo, Jr. - any
Mike Ditka - 1962 Topps #17 Mike Ditka RC
Art Donovan - 1952 Bowman Small #46 Art Donovan RC
Bill Dudley - 1948 Bowman #80 Bill Dudley RC
Albert Glen (Turk) Edwards - 1935 National Chicle #11A Turk Edwards SN RC
Carl Eller - 1965 Philadelphia #105 Carl Eller RC
John Elway
Tom Fears - 1950 Bowman #51 Tom Fears RC
Jim Finks - 1950 Bowman #128 Jim Finks RC
Frank Gatski - 1955 Bowman #119 Frank Gatski RC
Bill George - 1956 Topps #47 Bill George RC
Frank Gifford - 1952 Bowman Large #16 Frank Gifford RC
Otto Graham - 1950 Bowman #45 Otto Graham RC
Harold (Red) Grange - any
Bud Grant - any
Bob Griese - 1968 Topps #196 Bob Griese RC
Lou Groza - 1950 Bowman #6 Lou Groza RC
George Halas - 1952 Bowman Large #48 George Halas CO RC
Chris Hanburger - 1967 Philadelphia #183 Chris Hanburger RC
Bob Hayes - 1966 Philadelphia #58 Bob Hayes RC
Wilbur (Pete) Henry - 1955 Topps All American #100 Fats Henry SP RC
Gene Hickerson - 1966 Philadelphia #45 Gene Hickerson RC
Paul Hornung - 1957 Topps #151 Paul Hornung RC
Don Hutson - 1955 Topps All American #97 Don Hutson SP RC
Jerry Jones - any
Leroy Kelly - 1967 Philadelphia #43 Leroy Kelly RC
Jerry Kramer
Paul Krause - 1965 Philadelphia #189 Paul Krause RC
Tom Landry - 1951 Bowman #20 Tom Landry RC
Steve Largent - 1977 Topps #177 Steve Largent RC
Yale Lary - 1952 Bowman Large #140 Yale Lary RC
Bobby Layne - 1948 Leaf #6A Bobby Layne YP RC/(Yellow pants on front,/Name misspelled Bobbie)
Alphonse (Tuffy) Leemans - any
Bob Lilly - 1963 Topps #82 Bob Lilly SP RC
Vince Lombardi - any
Sid Luckman - 1948 Bowman #107 Sid Luckman RC
Wellington Mara - 1997 Topps Hall of Fame Class of 1997 #3 Wellington Mara
Gino Marchetti - 1952 Bowman Large #23 Gino Marchetti RC
Ollie Matson - 1952 Bowman Large #127 Ollie Matson SP RC
George McAfee - 1948 Leaf #19B George McAfee ERR RC/(Gorgeous George on front)
Tommy McDonald - 1957 Topps #124 Tommy McDonald DP RC
Hugh McElhenny - 1952 Bowman Large #29 Hugh McElhenny RC
Wayne Millner - 1952 Bowman Large #57 Wayne Millner CO RC
Ron Mix - 1960 Fleer #118 Ron Mix RC
Lenny Moore - 1956 Topps #60 Lenny Moore RC
Randy Moss
Marion Motley - 1950 Bowman #43 Marion Motley RC
Bronko Nagurski - 1935 National Chicle #34 Bronko Nagurski RC
Joe Namath - 1965 Topps #122 Joe Namath SP RC
Ernie Nevers - 1955 Topps All American #56 Ernie Nevers RC
Ray Nitschke - 1963 Topps #96 Ray Nitschke RC
Leo Nomellini - 1948 Leaf #52A Leo Nomellini BBMJ RC/(Blue Background, Maroon jersey)
Jim Otto - 1961 Topps #182 Jim Otto RC
Steve Owen - 1952 Bowman Small #4 Steve Owen CO RC
Terrell Owens
Clarence (Ace) Parker - 1955 Topps All American #84 Ace Parker SP RC
Joe Perry - 1950 Bowman #35 Joe Perry RC
Pete Pihos - 1948 Bowman #63 Pete Pihos SP RC
Bill Polian - any
John Randle - 1991 Pro Set #835 John Randle RC
Mel Renfro - 1965 Philadelphia #53 Mel Renfro RC
Les Richter - 1952 Bowman Large #61 Les Richter RC
Andy Robustelli - 1952 Bowman Large #85 Andy Robustelli RC
Gale Sayers 1966 Philadelphia #38 Gale Sayers RC
Joe Schmidt 1956 Topps #44 Joe Schmidt RC
Billy Shaw - 1962 Fleer #16 Billy Shaw RC
Ken Stabler - 1973 Topps #487 Ken Stabler RC
Bart Starr - 1957 Topps #119 Bart Starr RC
Roger Staubach 1972 Topps #200 Roger Staubach RC
Ernie Stautner 1949 Topps Felt Backs #79 Ernie Stautner RC
Joe Stydahar 1952 Bowman Small #99 Joe Stydahar CO RC
Fran Tarkenton 1962 Topps #90 Fran Tarkenton SP RC 225.00
Charley Taylor 1965 Philadelphia #195 Charley Taylor RC 50.00
Jason Taylor 1997 SP Authentic #116 Jason Taylor RC
Jim Thorpe 1955 Topps All American #37 400.00
Mick Tingelhoff 1964 Philadelphia #110 Mick Tingelhoff RC 6.00
Y.A. Tittle 1950 Bowman #5 Y.A.Tittle RC 250.00
Emlen Tunnell 1951 Bowman #91 Emlen Tunnell RC 100.00
Clyde Turner 1948 Bowman #36 Bulldog Turner SP RC 250.00
Johnny Unitas 1957 Topps #138 Johnny Unitas DP RC 450.00
Brian Urlacher
Norm Van Brocklin1951 Bowman #4 Norm Van Brocklin RC 300.00
Steve Van Buren 1948 Bowman #7 Steve Van Buren RC 200.00
Doak Walker 1948 Leaf #4A Doak Walker BYB RC/Bright yellow background) 200.00
Paul Warfield 1965 Philadelphia #41 Paul Warfield RC 90.00
Bob Waterfield 1948 Bowman #26 Bob Waterfield RC 200.00
Ralph Wilson, Jr. - No RC - any card
Alex Wojciechowicz 1948 Bowman #61 Alex Wojciechowicz RC 150.00
Rayfield Wright 1972 Topps #316 Rayfield Wright RC 50.00

 

[tom szczygiel]

I have these ;
1950 Bowman #35 Joe Perry
1950 Bowman #45 Otto Graham
1971 Topps #156 Bradshaw
1972 Topps #244 Charlie Joiner
1973 Topps #487 Ken Stabler
send me a email [email protected]

 

[BBonds25]

Glad to see I am not the only one who pc's HOF rc's. I just bought a card today that will put me over the 75% (193/258) completion rate for players (I list coaches separately) who have official rc's. It is a tough thing to build, but also super fun and exciting.

I happen to have an extra Ernie Nevers RC. Any chance you have any duplicate HOF rc's FT?

Thanks,
Brad

 

[reickholt]

If you are looking for Randy Moss I have many. Looking for anything specific?

 

[cjay101]

I have these ;
1950 Bowman #35 Joe Perry
1950 Bowman #45 Otto Graham
1971 Topps #156 Bradshaw
1972 Topps #244 Charlie Joiner
1973 Topps #487 Ken Stabler
send me a email [email protected]

Tom - i prefer to stay on site so I can keep track of things easier. What are you looking for in return? Scans/conditions/trade value?

Glad to see I am not the only one who pc's HOF rc's. I just bought a card today that will put me over the 75% (193/258) completion rate for players (I list coaches separately) who have official rc's. It is a tough thing to build, but also super fun and exciting.

I happen to have an extra Ernie Nevers RC. Any chance you have any duplicate HOF rc's FT?

Thanks,
Brad

Brad - all of my duplicates would be 80’s to current hofers. No vintage dupes. On coaches and pre-war players, i’m just picking up ‘any’ card - 74/75 fleer roll fills a lot of those spots. Just one of my many crazy side collections. What do you need for the Nevers?

If you are looking for Randy Moss I have many. Looking for anything specific?

With Moss, mainly auto/jsy/patch/key rookie/low serial stuff. I trade it all to my brother who collects him.

 

[SymphonicMetal]

It is mind blowing that you can still buy a 54 year old RC of a Hall of Famer for $6.00 like Mick Tingelhoff's rookie. Holy cow!

And I am pretty sure that Jerry Kramer's RC is a 1959 Topps. I noticed there was no card info by his name.

 

[reickholt]

I have two of these and would be willing to trade one.

1998 Collector's Choice Randy Moss ROOKIE INK RC autograph

One is blue ink the other is black. I've never been able to locate anything on the ink variation. Would love info you might have on the variation and LMK if interested in either.
Rick

Tom - i prefer to stay on site so I can keep track of things easier. What are you looking for in return? Scans/conditions/trade value?



Brad - all of my duplicates would be 80’s to current hofers. No vintage dupes. On coaches and pre-war players, i’m just picking up ‘any’ card - 74/75 fleer roll fills a lot of those spots. Just one of my many crazy side collections. What do you need for the Nevers?



With Moss, mainly auto/jsy/patch/key rookie/low serial stuff. I trade it all to my brother who collects him.

 

[cjay101]

It is mind blowing that you can still buy a 54 year old RC of a Hall of Famer for $6.00 like Mick Tingelhoff's rookie. Holy cow!

And I am pretty sure that Jerry Kramer's RC is a 1959 Topps. I noticed there was no card info by his name.

If only....most tinglehoffs sell much higher, that is just ‘book’

I didn’t get the most recent guys like Kramer added yet.

 

[cjay101]

I have two of these and would be willing to trade one.

1998 Collector's Choice Randy Moss ROOKIE INK RC autograph

One is blue ink the other is black. I've never been able to locate anything on the ink variation. Would love info you might have on the variation and LMK if interested in either.
Rick

Rick - i think you mean Edge and not Choice. The only ink variation I am aware of is red and they are numbered /45.

May be a scenario where a rookie WR had a marker run out and grabbed the next working one. I would be interested in either/both autographs. What are you looking for?