Would you do this trade? and what would you choose to go along witht he trade?

truffleshuffle0

New member
1
5.00 star(s)
I had a offer for my mark sanches 09 absolute rpm jersey/auto bv 200.

I would get a mark sanchez prestige prestigous picks autos bv 100 and one of these. what would you choose and why. and would you do the deal.

McFadden is #/15, books $100.

Ronnie Brown books $120, I can give it with the Sanchez.

I have a Matt Forte Spx Rookie jsy/auto, bv $80, I can give it and the Brandon Jacobs Signature Reflections rookie auto.
 

avstars

New member
64
5.00 star(s)
It really depends on your preference and what would work in a trade for you. I prefer the Sancehz auto/jersey end of the deal, but again whatever makes you happy.
 

97honda

New member
146
5.00 star(s)
I would keep the Sanchez you own. Odds are there will be a card worth more along the way you will want and wish you still had the Sanchez as equal bait. I always keep the higher cards unless it is actually something for the PC. There is a reason they are wanting to trade a sanchez $100 BV auto for the $200 its obvious. Don't do it.
 

Soxfan33

Active member
230
5.00 star(s)
I would keep the Sanchez you own. Odds are there will be a card worth more along the way you will want and wish you still had the Sanchez as equal bait. I always keep the higher cards unless it is actually something for the PC. There is a reason they are wanting to trade a sanchez $100 BV auto for the $200 its obvious. Don't do it.

+1

I'd keep the higher end card. You may be able to get another higher end card for your PC down the road. Just make sure you're getting the cards you really want in return if you trade. That's my advise. Let us know what you decide.

John
 

Soccerboi

New member
23
4.50 star(s)
keep the sanchez and brown.

get rid of the mcfadden immideatly before all of his status runs out as well as the matt forte!

Im optimistic about the Brandon Jacobs.
 

truffleshuffle0

New member
1
5.00 star(s)
I'd split it off and go with the Sanchez and the Brown...then flip the Brown for something I like lol.

I was thinking of doing the trade since Im, getting the prestige sanchez for my set and the ronnie brown. but I get a pm from him basicly sounding like he was saying I was lucky he desided to do the trade because he usualy dosen't trade a players auto + another auto for a higher end auto of the same person but since i am putting the set together he would do it. But I can also say I don;t normanly trade down with A higher end bv card for two cards. so I don;t know. I am waiting for him to get me a scan of the items.
 

mindbinge

New member
237
5.00 star(s)
if you trade down then he has nothing to complain about if the BV goes a little in your favor, to me doesn't matter if it's the same auto he's trading or not...BV to BV to me is the big picture and if you are taking 2 cards for one of your big hits then you are in the right to have the BV go in your favor a little...or at least thats how I usually trade.
 

truffleshuffle0

New member
1
5.00 star(s)
if you trade down then he has nothing to complain about if the BV goes a little in your favor, to me doesn't matter if it's the same auto he's trading or not...BV to BV to me is the big picture and if you are taking 2 cards for one of your big hits then you are in the right to have the BV go in your favor a little...or at least thats how I usually trade.
See the thing is he offerd the trade up to me. I didn;t offer it to him. he gave me a option of the prestige sanchez auto and the brown or the prestige sanchez auto and a forte spx auto and something else. Thats what I don;t get about the pm I got from him.
 

truffleshuffle0

New member
1
5.00 star(s)
i dunno? but I'd take the Brown and another Sanchez for the bigger hit Sanchez lol...but that's just me.
I am planning on takeing the deal but would like some scans of the spx auto just to see what it looks like. and would like to see the scan of the sanchez. Im just waiting on a pm from him.
 

truffleshuffle0

New member
1
5.00 star(s)
Well I took the deal only because I was getting another sanchez auto in exchange and it was for my set. But i looked up the value of the brown and it didn;t book 120 it booked 100. But I went ahead and did the deal. Although I didn;t realy belive his reasoning for why the card didn;t book 120
 

truffleshuffle0

New member
1
5.00 star(s)
So 4/5 tell you not to do the trade, but you did. Why ask for advice then?
My question was more of what to go along with the trade more than to do it or not. Main reason I did the trade was that since I got a offer for the stafford I needed for the set from a member here I figured I would get the sanchez. It was even bv and I know I traded down a bit for it but I also got a sanchez auto so I didn;t lose that much in the deal and got a nice card for my set.
 
Top