New Charity Undertaking

Which set should we build for charity?

  • 2007 Topps Red Backs

    Votes: 8 28.6%

  • 2008 Topps Gold Foil

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • 1994 Upper Deck Electric Diamond

    Votes: 5 17.9%

  • 1994 UD Collectors Choice Silver Signature

    Votes: 2 7.1%

  • Topps Gold Border (Series I/Series II/Update) - year TBD

    Votes: 6 21.4%

  • Topps Rainbow Foil (Series I/Series II/Update) - year TBD

    Votes: 7 25.0%
  • Total voters
    28
  • Poll closed .

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

katester44

katester44

MVP
1,614
5.00 star(s)
Staff member
Joined
Apr 29, 2008
Messages
15,640
Location
Pennsylvania
Because I don't have enough going on in my life, my stupid brain that never shuts off decided it was time for another undertaking!
That undertaking is another set build for charity - with the success of the Yankee Stadium Legacy set, it feels like it is time once again for The Bench to work on some philanthropy. We donated to cancer research last time, this time I would like to help our veterans and first responders and make our donation to Tunnels 2 Towers.

Please vote on the attached poll and let us know what you would like to help us build. If we decide to go with one of the non-specific builds, we will have a second poll to determine which year to go after. If you have any questions or additional suggestions, please feel free to load up the thread. Poll will be open until October 28th.

Thank you and we look forward to your support and participation!!!
 
Scobes said:
Hi -

Good thinking! From those options, Topps Gold seems like it would net the most money.

Scobes
Click to expand...

Make sure you cast a vote!!! Several sets were under consideration, tried to pick the ones that would be easiest to build, would net the most and wouldn't cost us an arm and a leg to procure!

With all the sets, if every member could submit/find 1 card, we would knock it out in a heartbeat!
 
I voted for red backs. I loved that 2007 set... One I was attempting to build but gave up on about 1/3 of the way.
 
Scobes said:
Hi -

Good thinking! From those options, Topps Gold seems like it would net the most money.

Scobes
Click to expand...
The only issue with that is every year will have at least one card that will be hard or expensive to do. Think of the gold RCs. Who would be willing to donate a gold RC of a superstar?

2011 - no way. Trout RC
2012 - Harper
2013 - Arenado
2014 - Mookie
2015 - Lindor
2016 - okay, maybe we could do this one
2017 - Judge
2018 - Ohtani, Acuna, Soto not touching this one
2019 - Tatis
2020 - we may be able to do this one as well
2021 - Chisholm might be pricey
2022 - Witt
2023 - Carroll, Gunnar
2024 - Skenes

So really maybe 2016 and 2020.
 
Dashcol said:
The only issue with that is every year will have at least one card that will be hard or expensive to do. Think of the gold RCs. Who would be willing to donate a gold RC of a superstar?

2011 - no way. Trout RC
2012 - Harper
2013 - Arenado
2014 - Mookie
2015 - Lindor
2016 - okay, maybe we could do this one
2017 - Judge
2018 - Ohtani, Acuna, Soto not touching this one
2019 - Tatis
2020 - we may be able to do this one as well
2021 - Chisholm might be pricey
2022 - Witt
2023 - Carroll, Gunnar
2024 - Skenes

So really maybe 2016 and 2020.
Click to expand...

@Dashcol

Good point. It's just out of the options presented, I thought a Gold Set would do the best. Maybe an update set? Or an older Gold Set?

Scobes
 
I'm thinking a chrome parallel might be interesting. Maybe one #/50. Any cards that I would be able to contribute are long gone however.
 
Dashcol said:
The only issue with that is every year will have at least one card that will be hard or expensive to do. Think of the gold RCs. Who would be willing to donate a gold RC of a superstar?

2011 - no way. Trout RC
2012 - Harper
2013 - Arenado
2014 - Mookie
2015 - Lindor
2016 - okay, maybe we could do this one
2017 - Judge
2018 - Ohtani, Acuna, Soto not touching this one
2019 - Tatis
2020 - we may be able to do this one as well
2021 - Chisholm might be pricey
2022 - Witt
2023 - Carroll, Gunnar
2024 - Skenes

So really maybe 2016 and 2020.
Click to expand...
If it comes down to a big card or two, you never know who may step up and donate one for charity. If not, we can pool $$ donation to buy one. I think all but w handful of years are solid options. Definitely stay away from 18
 
cjay101 said:
If it comes down to a big card or two, you never know who may step up and donate one for charity. If not, we can pool $$ donation to buy one. I think all but w handful of years are solid options. Definitely stay away from 18
Click to expand...
Yes, 18 is out of the question IMO. I am sure we could get enough donations to cover big cards is need be.

I think 2011 is a no go too. Trout may have dropped A LOT, based on injuries and severe drop off in performance, but a gold 2011 update Trout will still run us $800-900.

I think that is better spent on another set that can be had all in on that set for well under that and give close to that for a charity.

I voted for 2007 red backs, but now am really thinking 2016 Gold would be a good one too.
 
I'm on the thought that anything outside the last decade is a no go:
1)so many people who had them available have moved them
2)no one is going to be ripping open of the product
3)less "exciting' players for newcomers to the hobby and sport.

Also, I've collected cards for 35 years, I had to go back and look up 2007 red backs because I didn't remember them. I remember silver signature and electric diamond but they fall outside my 10 year lookback. I think just about every baseball collector known to man knows the Topps Gold parallel.
 
Dashcol said:
The only issue with that is every year will have at least one card that will be hard or expensive to do. Think of the gold RCs. Who would be willing to donate a gold RC of a superstar?

2011 - no way. Trout RC
2012 - Harper
2013 - Arenado
2014 - Mookie
2015 - Lindor
2016 - okay, maybe we could do this one
2017 - Judge
2018 - Ohtani, Acuna, Soto not touching this one
2019 - Tatis
2020 - we may be able to do this one as well
2021 - Chisholm might be pricey
2022 - Witt
2023 - Carroll, Gunnar
2024 - Skenes

So really maybe 2016 and 2020.
Click to expand...

Thanks for throwing this list together. Definitely lays out what is possible v. what might not be possible.

Definitely keep the suggestions coming - the ultimate goal is to do these charity set builds on a fairly regular basis. So even if we don't do a particular set this time, it will be up for discussion next time.

Also hoping that we can knock this one out a lot quicker than it took us to do the YSL set.
 
Amen to that. The ysl took forever!
I think you could do a foil set quickly so I'm going for that one.
 
The masses have spoken (although a lot more votes would have been nice) - looks like the 2007 Red Backs is the set to build. I will get a thread started to keep track of this project.

I have a stack of probably 60-70 or so sitting on the desk right now, so we are about 10% of the way there on day 1.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

katester44
The 17th Annual Benchies
Replies
12
Views
655
katester44
katester44
ballards
New 90's sets to build...
Replies
1
Views
210
ballards
ballards
katester44
15th Annual Benchies
2
Replies
22
Views
3K
doniceage
D
J
New card shop
Replies
3
Views
1K
JAMIEnBRAD
J
Nomahlovesyah
2024 Allen & Ginter Lot F/T
Replies
0
Views
117
Nomahlovesyah
Nomahlovesyah

Sponsors

Latest posts and bumps

Members online

Total: 137 (members: 18, guests: 119)
Back
Top