(4) 2013 Bowman Draft & (1) Chrome Aaron Judge #BDPP19 For Trade

[Sportnut08]

I'm seeing:



2011 Topps Update Anthony Rizzo RC #US55 $7
https://www.comc.com/Cards/Baseball/2011/Topps_Update_Series_-_Base/US55/Anthony_Rizzo/5568536

2014 Topps Update Mookie Betts RC #US26 $15
https://www.comc.com/Cards/Baseball...ies_-_Base/US-261/Mookie_Betts_(Base)/9468456

2014 Topps Chrome Update Mookie Betts #US20 $30
https://www.comc.com/Cards/Baseball...te_-_Mega_Box_Base/US-20/Mookie_Betts/9661265

2015 Topps Update Carlos Correa RC #US174 $8

https://www.comc.com/Cards/Baseball...s_-_Base/US1741/Carlos_Correa_(Base)/10814962

If I'm not mistaken, that looks like the trade would be in your favor ($60 vs $45), with a $15 margin of error.

I'm looking at completed sales. Chrome Betts 22, 16.52, 17.52...so about $18

Betts update $9.95, $10, $9.99...$10

Correa update $3.59, $4.50, $4.55, $5.33...$4.50

Rizzo update $4.99, $5.25, $5.99....$5.50

I come up with about $38. Throw in Altuve and we have a deal.

Thanks
Kirby

 

[ichiro51]

I'm looking at completed sales. Chrome Betts 22, 16.52, 17.52...so about $18

Betts update $9.95, $10, $9.99...$10

Correa update $3.59, $4.50, $4.55, $5.33...$4.50

Rizzo update $4.99, $5.25, $5.99....$5.50

I come up with about $38. Throw in Altuve and we have a deal.

Thanks
Kirby

I can't do that - I think my offer was pretty fair.

Thanks for the responses, though.

 

[Sportnut08]

I can't do that - I think my offer was pretty fair.

Thanks for the responses, though.

No problem. Not looking to trade the hottest player at a discount.

 

[ichiro51]

No problem. Not looking to trade the hottest player at a discount.

I'm not asking you to do that.

There is a small discrepancy in values, which I still do not agree with. I'll throw in $5 cash with the cards to make up the difference.

 

[Sportnut08]

I'm not asking you to do that.

There is a small discrepancy in values, which I still do not agree with. I'll throw in $5 cash with the cards to make up the difference.

No thanks. You're quoting unsold listings as sale values and I'm looking at completed sales. It's not the same. I'm sure someone will be willing to trade at market value for them so I'll pass.

 

[ichiro51]

No thanks. You're quoting unsold listings as sale values and I'm looking at completed sales. It's not the same. I'm sure someone will be willing to trade at market value for them so I'll pass.

I offered an additional $5 to bring my lot total up to what your Judge lot total is for completed listings.

 

[Sportnut08]

I offered an additional $5 to bring my lot total up to what your Judge lot total is for completed listings.

I saw that and I said no.

 

[ichiro51]

I saw that and I said no.

What is your problem?

We made a great trade where I sacrificed value to you a week ago and now you are showing no flexibility in order to make a deal for specific cards you are asking for.

 

[Sportnut08]

What is your problem?

We made a great trade where I sacrificed value to you a week ago and now you are showing no flexibility in order to make a deal for specific cards you are asking for.

My problem is when people don't want to trade for something at market value. If you don't want to do that, please don't waste my time and move along.

 

[ichiro51]

My problem is when people don't want to trade for something at market value. If you don't want to do that, please don't waste my time and move along.

How did I not?
I offered you an equal amount.

Also, you are one to talk...trading by BV's when it is convenient for you to take advantage of the situation.

Your trade above was SIGNIFICANTLY in your favor with the difference in BV vs. SV. Did you ask baseball jack to trade by Sell Value? Nope, because you completely ripped him off.

"BV's from July beckett

Bryant 2015 Topps # 616 $ 10
Bryant 2015 Topps Mini # 616 $12
Harper 2012 Topps Update # US 183 $10
Correa 2015 Topps Update # US174 (2) $ 2.50 each
Correa 2015 Topps Update Chrome # US174 $ 20
Correa 2015 Topps Update # US251 (M) (5) $1.50 each
Arenado 2013 Topps Update # US259 $ 3"

I bet you didn't show him the completed listings for the cards above, especially the 2012 Update Harper which I just also traded to you, but at a $50 value since that's what it sells for.

Next time look in the mirror before you call the kettle black, pot.

 

[Sportnut08]

How did I not?
I offered you an equal amount.

Also, you are one to talk...trading by BV's when it is convenient for you to take advantage of the situation.

Your trade above was SIGNIFICANTLY in your favor with the difference in BV vs. SV. Did you ask baseball jack to trade by Sell Value? Nope, because you completely ripped him off.

"BV's from July beckett

Bryant 2015 Topps # 616 $ 10
Bryant 2015 Topps Mini # 616 $12
Harper 2012 Topps Update # US 183 $10
Correa 2015 Topps Update # US174 (2) $ 2.50 each
Correa 2015 Topps Update Chrome # US174 $ 20
Correa 2015 Topps Update # US251 (M) (5) $1.50 each
Arenado 2013 Topps Update # US259 $ 3"

I bet you didn't show him the completed listings for the cards above, especially the 2012 Update Harper which I just also traded to you, but at a $50 value since that's what it sells for.

Next time look in the mirror before you call the kettle black, pot.

If people want to trade by BV, I'll trade by BV. If people want to trade by SV, I'll trade by SV, so long as they understand what SV is. I've never traded by list value before though.

And speaking of trying to rip people off. Your initial offer on our last trade was about $140 in your favor.

 

[RHauch]

Thread closed.