Hold or trade? What do you think? Jac Caglianone /150

[YankeesFan0428]

Hi all, I pulled a 2025 Bowman Jac chrome blue raywave /150 - it books $120 (with the little green up-up-up arrow). I'm sitting on it and just unsure what to do. I PC Yankees and low-end HOF autos mostly. What do you think, do I hold and hope he explodes? Do I just trade for some cool stuff I'll be happy with? I'm leaning towards trade but stuck in a loop of uncertainty.

 

[K.C._Royals!]

Hi all, I pulled a 2025 Bowman Jac chrome blue raywave /150 - it books $120 (with the little green up-up-up arrow). I'm sitting on it and just unsure what to do. I PC Yankees and low-end HOF autos mostly. What do you think, do I hold and hope he explodes? Do I just trade for some cool stuff I'll be happy with? I'm leaning towards trade but stuck in a loop of uncertainty.

I'd love it if you traded it to me --- Cags is my dude! However, all my $100+ Yankees and HOF auto traders have been long since been moved... but, hey! if I pull a Judge auto or something else really interesting you might like down the line I'll check back in with you.

 

[chief wahoo]

I would hold. He's really struggling and his prices have plummeted.

 

[YankeesFan0428]

@K.C._Royals! I would consider lower Yankees and HOF autos if you have ones that I need. Doesn't have to be one for one.

 

[YankeesFan0428]

I would hold. He's really struggling and his prices have plummeted.

Definitely one of the reasons I haven't traded yet for sure

 

[SymphonicMetal]

I would trade it for HOF autos. The chances of any of these prospects ending up being HOFers is a long shot at best. Sure he is a prospect but he is 22 years old and certainly not on the level of phenoms like Griffey Jr and Irod who were kicking butt in the Bigs as teens. Most of these prospects end up being suspects and end up forgotten in the dustbin of baseball history. Take the sure bet.

 

[Scobes]

I would trade it for HOF autos. The chances of any of these prospects ending up being HOFers is a long shot at best. Sure he is a prospect but he is 22 years old and certainly not on the level of phenoms like Griffey Jr and Irod who were kicking butt in the Bigs as teens. Most of these prospects end up being suspects and end up forgotten in the dustbin of baseball history. Take the sure bet.

I agree with this! There's a decent chance that 5 years down the road he won't even be in the bigs - take the sure thing here!

Scobes

 

[yankees1]

I have several volpe autos if Interested

 

[YankeesFan0428]

@yankees1 shows how much volpe has gone down in my mind. I appreciate it, but would rather trade for a bunch of low-end HOF autos than a volpe.

 

[zlw1]

It's a good hold right now. Just like Kurtz was earlier this year, and now look, his stuff just exploded. What wouldn't sell for $5 last week is going for $50.

Same thing will happen to Cags.

 

[CoralCityCards]

I have the same dillema, I just got a 2025 Bowman Chrome 14/99 (Number Match) Green Jac Caglianone in a break. I don't know what it's value is.

 

[YankeesFan0428]

@CoralCityCards if it’s a non-auto green of bcp103, it books $150. If it’s an insert, less. An auto, much more.

 

[CoralCityCards]

@CoralCityCards if it’s a non-auto green of bcp103, it books $150. If it’s an insert, less. An auto, much more.

Thanks, it's not an auto. It's one of the coolest cards I've ever had.