Would this work for you?
Bo Jackson
1988 Donruss Baseball's Best #119 (0.40)
1989 Bowman #126 (0.25)
1991 Donruss Highlights BC-10 (0.25)
2008 Upper Deck Baseball Heroes #81 (1.25)
2010 Topps Legendary Lineage LL-44 w/Upton (1.25)
2010 Topps Cards Your Mom Threw Out (Original Back) #153 Eddie Murray ($4)
2013 Topps Archives #146 Eddie Murray ($1)
2013 Topps 1972 Mini TM-45 Cal Ripken ($6)
1991 Panini Stickers #192 Cal Ripken ($3)
2008 Upper Deck Infield Power IP-DJ Jeter ($4)
2008 Upper Deck Yankee Stadium Legacy #6077 Jeter ($8)
2008 Upper Deck Spectrum Retrospectrum DJ68 Jeter ($4)
2008 Upper Deck Heroes #111 Rivera (1.25)
2009 Upper Deck #273 Rivera ($1)
2010 Topps #404 Rivera ($1)
2012 Topps Heritage #43 Rivera w/Girardi ($1)
2013 Topps Opening Day #176 Rivera (0.75)
BV: $38.40
For me...
1990 Topps #4 Nolan Ryan (0.50)
1999 Upper Deck Retro #89 Nolan Ryan ($3)
2001 Topps Gallery #142 Nolan Ryan ($6)
2003 Sweet Spot Classic #63 Nolan Ryan ($6)
2004 Leaf Exhibits 1925 Right Text Box Second Edition #6 Nolan Ryan (Mets) ($12)
2005 SP Legendary Cuts #57 Nolan Ryan ($5)
2002 Donruss Diamond Kings #6 Albert Pujols ($2.50)
2004 Topps #344 Albert Pujols w/ Todd Helton and Juan Pierre (0.75)
2005 Topps Total #495 Albert Pujols (1.25)
$37
Bo Jackson
1988 Donruss Baseball's Best #119 (0.40)
1989 Bowman #126 (0.25)
1991 Donruss Highlights BC-10 (0.25)
2008 Upper Deck Baseball Heroes #81 (1.25)
2010 Topps Legendary Lineage LL-44 w/Upton (1.25)
2010 Topps Cards Your Mom Threw Out (Original Back) #153 Eddie Murray ($4)
2013 Topps Archives #146 Eddie Murray ($1)
2013 Topps 1972 Mini TM-45 Cal Ripken ($6)
1991 Panini Stickers #192 Cal Ripken ($3)
2008 Upper Deck Infield Power IP-DJ Jeter ($4)
2008 Upper Deck Yankee Stadium Legacy #6077 Jeter ($8)
2008 Upper Deck Spectrum Retrospectrum DJ68 Jeter ($4)
2008 Upper Deck Heroes #111 Rivera (1.25)
2009 Upper Deck #273 Rivera ($1)
2010 Topps #404 Rivera ($1)
2012 Topps Heritage #43 Rivera w/Girardi ($1)
2013 Topps Opening Day #176 Rivera (0.75)
BV: $38.40
For me...
1990 Topps #4 Nolan Ryan (0.50)
1999 Upper Deck Retro #89 Nolan Ryan ($3)
2001 Topps Gallery #142 Nolan Ryan ($6)
2003 Sweet Spot Classic #63 Nolan Ryan ($6)
2004 Leaf Exhibits 1925 Right Text Box Second Edition #6 Nolan Ryan (Mets) ($12)
2005 SP Legendary Cuts #57 Nolan Ryan ($5)
2002 Donruss Diamond Kings #6 Albert Pujols ($2.50)
2004 Topps #344 Albert Pujols w/ Todd Helton and Juan Pierre (0.75)
2005 Topps Total #495 Albert Pujols (1.25)
$37