M&M My Pros and Cons

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

TJCloutier

Pro
75
5.00 star(s)
Joined
Apr 23, 2008
Messages
1,608
Location
Maine
Well assuming everyone knows about the 4 different variations of Moments and Milestones... you all know it's very frustrating and can get extremely expensive. For the 2008 set for Sheffield there are:
480 White Home Run Cards /150
480 Black Home Run Cards /25
480 Blue Home Run Cards /10
480 Red Home Run Cards /1

Now all sets are difficult as everyone knows, white because pretty expensive and so on the further down the variation list you go. With my knowledge of completing 1 full White set with 475/480 cards of another set, 3/4 of a black set, and almost half of a blue set... these are my pros and cons as a player collector and a collector in general that I have procured.

*Keep in mind that each player you collect doesn't always have 480 cards in the set nor could it be close to that at all.

Pros:
-Cards look very nice when completed, many collectors understand the hardship of trying to find particular cards and if no one has it for sale then you almost want to just go break open a box to find it! Even though that would be a terrible solution :p

-Putting together one of these sets let alone multiple is nearly impossible depending on what variation you're going for. White is possible most of the time, black is very difficult, blue is near impossible considering the /10 print run, and red is out of the question since their all 1/1's. However once you complete one of the sets or are close to completing it it feels great considering how tough these are in fact to put together.

-Taking on the task of one of these sets is enduring but hey it gives you something to do as a collector. If you have your collection organized and are just picking up new things here and there and not doing much lately with your collection then why not start a nice m & m set? :)

Cons
-Time and patience. For two years I've needed #455 (white variation) of the Sheffield Home run moment and milestone. The card isn't too scarce because its print run is 150 but for some reason I cannot find another after I've completed my first set. This is what I mean by time and patience. After putting together all the work for the majority of the set I just basically need that card. I need about 10 other cards for the set but I can purchase all of those once I get #455. You need to have patience or you'll have nothing! P.S see #455 and shoot me a pm! :p

-Money. I've spent hundreds on this set. The first set that was put together mainly by my father before he passed cost hundreds to complete. After his passing I purchased many many of the black versions to try to do that set, and tried to put together my own white variation as well to maybe try to resell. One Sheffield 1/1 red moment goes for around 6 bucks plus shipping. You'll never complete this variation so it's not really worth shelling any money into no matter who you collect. Their neat to get but not worth the money. Try a white set, then go for black. Pick up the others as you go for cheap is the best advice I can give!


Conclusion: I really just wanted to share my thoughts on the set and really had nothing better to do. Just to give a little insights on what I was thinking today :) Many of you will be like wow we all already knew this for years, while others may be interested. I have no idea, but thanks for the read!
 
Interesting read... I feel your pain as im trying to put together a maddux collection which has 347 cards. When they first came out i thought it would be impossible to obtain a full set of any of the variations unless one spent alot of money. I bought four boxes and started trading for the ones i needed. I was lucky enough to run into a trader on here who traded me 500+ of the white, 175+ black, 65+ blue & 5+ of the red in numerous trades for YSL cards. Im down to only needing three cards for the first set & at 83% on the second white set. I buy them here & there but the shipping charges usually make it not worth purchasing. Its is a fun set to put together trading specially with the low print runs but can get expensive fast buying them. The only thing i dont like about the set is theres only four different photes of maddux for 347 cards.

If anyone is interested, i do have some for trade http://madduxfan3131.webs.com/08toppsmmudheroes.htm
 
Last edited:
Interesting read... I feel your pain as im trying to put together a maddux collection which has 347 cards. When they first came out i thought it would be impossible to obtain a full set of any of the variations unless one spent alot of money. I bought four boxes and started trading for the ones i needed. I was lucky enough to run into a trader on here who traded me 500+ of the white, 175+ black, 65+ blue & 5+ of the red in numerous trades for YSL cards. Im down to only needing three cards for the first set & at 83% on the second white set. I buy them here & there but the shipping charges usually make it not worth purchasing. Its is a fun set to put together trading specially with the low print runs but can get expensive fast buying them. The only thing i dont like about the set is theres only four different photes of maddux for 347 cards.

If anyone is interested, i do have some for trade http://madduxfan3131.webs.com/08toppsmmudheroes.htm

was his name something like jibjab or chris jab?
 
Congrats on getting that 1st white set and close on the 2nd!

I am trying for the white, but I am realizing that the black, blue, and red will be nearly impossible.

So... anyone have any Miguel Cabrera M&M to trade? :D
 
I was lucky I got 303 Glavine white #/150 gave up on the Black #/25 and just got one Mets and one Braves #1/1
Jack
 
i know your pain!
finished the tim lincecum white, 1/2 way through the black a handful of the blue, but I have managed to get 13 of the reds!!!
I have these sheffields if you need any - please pm.
MARLINS GARY SHEFFIELD TOPPS MOMENTS AND MILESTONES BLACK 2008 52-116 07/25
MARLINS GARY SHEFFIELD TOPPS MOMENTS AND MILESTONES BLACK 2008 52-154 03/25
MARLINS GARY SHEFFIELD TOPPS MOMENTS AND MILESTONES BLACK 2008 52-162 08/25
BRAVES GARY SHEFFIELD TOPPS MOMENTS AND MILESTONES BLACK 2008 52-362 06/25
TIGERS GARY SHEFFIELD TOPPS MOMENTS AND MILESTONES BLACK 2008 52-460 17/25
TIGERS GARY SHEFFIELD TOPPS MOMENTS AND MILESTONES BLACK 2008 52-472 13/25
DODGERS GARY SHEFFIELD TOPPS MOMENTS AND MILESTONES BLUE 2008 52-233 03/10
TIGERS GARY SHEFFIELD TOPPS MOMENTS AND MILESTONES BLUE 2008 52-467 04/10
MARLINS GARY SHEFFIELD TOPPS MOMENTS AND MILESTONES BLUE 2008 52-87 06/10
 
Have these Sheffields:

2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 39 Home Runs #145/150
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 64 Home Runs #146/150
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 70 Home Runs #030/150
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 182 Home Runs #084/150
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 216 Home Runs #037/150
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 239 Home Runs #099/150
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 287 Home Runs #085/150
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 366 Home Runs #037/150
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 392 Home Runs #147/150
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 405 Home Runs #024/150
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 407 Home Runs Black #04/25
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 445 Home Runs Black #20/25
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 450 Home Runs Black #24/25
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 456 Home Runs #006/150
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 462 Home Runs Blue #09/10
 
Have these Sheffields:

2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 39 Home Runs #145/150
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 64 Home Runs #146/150
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 70 Home Runs #030/150
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 182 Home Runs #084/150
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 216 Home Runs #037/150
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 239 Home Runs #099/150
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 287 Home Runs #085/150
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 366 Home Runs #037/150
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 392 Home Runs #147/150
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 405 Home Runs #024/150
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 407 Home Runs Black #04/25
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 445 Home Runs Black #20/25
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 450 Home Runs Black #24/25
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 456 Home Runs #006/150
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones 52 462 Home Runs Blue #09/10

I'd only really be interested in the blue... I mean I'd take them all but I wouldn't have much to trade for them. I usually buy any you're not allowed to yet.
 
Pros:
-Cards look very nice when completed, many collectors understand the hardship of trying to find particular cards and if no one has it for sale then you almost want to just go break open a box to find it! Even though that would be a terrible solution :p

-Putting together one of these sets let alone multiple is nearly impossible depending on what variation you're going for. White is possible most of the time, black is very difficult, blue is near impossible considering the /10 print run, and red is out of the question since their all 1/1's. However once you complete one of the sets or are close to completing it it feels great considering how tough these are in fact to put together.

-Taking on the task of one of these sets is enduring but hey it gives you something to do as a collector. If you have your collection organized and are just picking up new things here and there and not doing much lately with your collection then why not start a nice m & m set? :)

Cons
-Time and patience.

Continue your huny...the chase is FUN!

Time and patience is a PRO as nothing is "fun" when you can finish it too fast ;)
 
Man, I can't imagine going after some of these player sets! I'm going after the Jeff Kent 2008 set (because Ryno is mentioned on the back :D) and struggle with it. Kudos to all of you who are near finishing one set.
 
I've managed to finish all 207 of the Smoltz white 2008 set. I need 12 more to finish the 2008 black set. And I have just barely over half of the 2008 blue set. And finally, I've managed to get 7 of the red set.


However, it is getting much tougher to get them. People just aren't opening any more boxes of these and many of the parallels are not getting into circulation, making it much tougher to add to my collection.
 
Top