Jason (yosoysoy) - I took the 2012 Update Black Tyler Moore out as well which puts the value that I'm receiving at $199.75 and the value that you would receive at $201. Please let me know if that works for you. Thanks!
1998 UD3 #219 Tino Martinez rainbow $2 ($3)
2003 Topps T205 drum #229 Mike Mussina $2.50 ($4)
2003 Topps T205 polar bear #236 Bernie Williams $1 ($1.50)
Mantle HRH: 387, 392, 401, 443, 460, 529 - $2 each $12 Total
2006 Ultimate #1 Ruth /799 $15
2007 Exquisite gold #145 Igawa AU #’d /25 $60
2007 Topps Arod Road to 500 #208 $3
2007 UD Masterpieces #3 Bobby Thompson #’d /50 $2.50 (non-Yankee)
2007 UD Masterpieces windsor green #7 Larson $1.50 ($1.25)
2007 UD Masterpieces windsor green #9 Maris $3
2008 UD YSL: #1057 Red Rolfe $3, 1219 Joe McCarthy $3, 2642 Hank Bauer $3, 2667 Don Larson $3, 2692 Whitey Ford $3, 2742 Yogi Berra $3, 2744 Yogi Berra $3, 2769 Hank Bauer $3, 2783 Hank Bauer $3, 2877 Gil McDougald $3, 5501 Wade Boggs $3, 6619 A Rod $6 - $39 total
2011 Finest Finest Moments FM13 A Rod $4
2011 Topps Toys R Us #PDC5 A Rod $5
2003 Bowman Chrome x-fractor #10 Jorge Posada $4.50 ($5)
2005 Playoff Prestige League Leaders #LLS-1 Gary Sheffield bat /250 $10 ($8)
2007 Topps Chrome x-fractor #16 Andy Pettitte $3
2007 Topps Mickey Mantle Story #MMS44 $2
2008 Topps Replica Mini-jersey #CPR-AR Alex Rodriguez /539 $25
2010 Topps Chrome blue refractor #95 AJ Burnett /199 $6
Total - $201 ($199.75)
2008 Topps Update black #94 Volquez/Martin $10 ($15)
2008 Topps Update black #308 Shelley Duncan $10
2008 Topps Update black #309 John Bowker $10
2009 Topps Update black #22 Brett Gardner $10 ($12)
2009 Topps Update black #246 Javier Vazquez $10 ($12)
2009 Topps Update black #262 Jeff Niemann $10 ($12)
2009 Topps Update black #98 Hanley Ramirez $15
2010 Triple Threads gold: 12 Kaline $6, 15 Ellsbury $6, 24 Cobb $10, 25 Christy Mathewson $2.50 ($6), 45 Prince $4, 97 Matt Kemp $6
2011 Topps Update black #314 Armando Galarraga $10
2012 Topps Black #287 Antonio Bastardo $10
2012 Topps Black #327 Mark Kotsay $10
Griffey
1997 Pacific Prisms Sizzling Lumber #6A $10
1999 Crown Royale Pillars of the Game #22 $2
2000 Pacific Ornaments #18 $6
2004 Leather and Lumber silver #42 /100 $12
2007 Topps Co-Signers silver bronze #21A /175 $4 ($2)
2007 UD Ken Griffey Jr Chronicles #20, 41, 45 - $5 each $15 Total
Total: $218.50 ($201)