UPDATE: Seller said he would take it down and contact Upper Deck about it. Said he didn't know of the forgery.
To make a side note I never flat out accused this seller of doing it himself. I don't jump to conclusions especially of people with high feedback which makes it obvious he's just selling mass amounts of cards and quickly scanning/uploading pictures so it could be a common mistake.
I reported it earlier. This signature isn't even close to Sheffields. I own 400+ autos of him and have never seen something such as this. I know for a fact that either this owner or a previous went over the faded signature with sharpie and did a TERRIBLE job at that.
I own 3 of these of the /20 and have been pretty proud of owning the 3 since this is Sheffields highest booking card as far as I'm concerned. ALL MY AUTOS HAVE ALMOST FADED COMPLETELY. You can notice on this card in the auction the black where this auto was and how he tried covering it up. I would NEVER pay for something as atrocious looking as this even if I know the auto was on it at one point, it was destroyed by another individual.
Please help me by reporting this as well! thanks.
Pictures of the 3 I own. Notice how bad the autographs are. They have seen NO sunlight and have been in case and box since 2004. All have faded. You can see this is the SAME fade as the auction up for sale.
Auction of fake Sheffield autograph
Auction of authentic Sheffield autograph I won the other day



To make a side note I never flat out accused this seller of doing it himself. I don't jump to conclusions especially of people with high feedback which makes it obvious he's just selling mass amounts of cards and quickly scanning/uploading pictures so it could be a common mistake.
I reported it earlier. This signature isn't even close to Sheffields. I own 400+ autos of him and have never seen something such as this. I know for a fact that either this owner or a previous went over the faded signature with sharpie and did a TERRIBLE job at that.
I own 3 of these of the /20 and have been pretty proud of owning the 3 since this is Sheffields highest booking card as far as I'm concerned. ALL MY AUTOS HAVE ALMOST FADED COMPLETELY. You can notice on this card in the auction the black where this auto was and how he tried covering it up. I would NEVER pay for something as atrocious looking as this even if I know the auto was on it at one point, it was destroyed by another individual.
Please help me by reporting this as well! thanks.
Pictures of the 3 I own. Notice how bad the autographs are. They have seen NO sunlight and have been in case and box since 2004. All have faded. You can see this is the SAME fade as the auction up for sale.
Auction of fake Sheffield autograph
Auction of authentic Sheffield autograph I won the other day



Last edited: