Which Patch Auto Would You Keep?

[Soxfan33]

Hey guys,

I picked up a second Papelbon 08 Masterpieces patch/auto recently. I forgot that I already had one. So now I'm trying to decide which to keep. I will be trading the one I don't keep. Both have similar centering and neither has a defect.

Left or Right? You can vote up top!

I'm leaning toward the Right.

Thanks,
John

 

[ckinney]

Kind of a hard choice, I like the patch on the right, but the auto on the left... I know it doesn't help... but I voted.

- Chris

 

[basebal1fan]

I think that whichever one you keep, you will be happy. But, I like the patch on the right a little better. They're both great cards though!

 

[cardboardcrazy]

I like the patch on the right, the auto on the left..lol.. So I guess the real question is are you collectiong it for the auto or the patch ??

 

[vktwinsfan24]

left. Patch and auto better in my opinion...

 

[metsman1986]

I voted right, like the patch better.......................Auto's look similar................Very nice cards!

Mike

 

[Motown G]

Right. Nicer patch!

 

[benob1knob]

The autograph on the left is better but the patch on the right is nicer. I say keep the one on the right.

 

[katester44]

Voted right. Like the third color on the patch.

 

[David K.]

Voted...going for the card with the three colored patch. Best regards, David

 

[bonzomoretti]

3 colors vs. 2 colors...I go with 3 everyday! Auto is an Auto. As long as it doesn't run off the card or is smeared.

 

[blueted007]

I voted for the patch and auto on the left,its lower # ed.

Jon

 

[criollos]

I'm an auto collector and don't care for patches,.....so I voted left.

 

[Boots]

As others have opined, I like the auto on the left and the patch on the right. Since I collect neither, the deciding factors for me were:
1.) left is lower #'d;
2.) the green background behind his head appears darker on the left, more similar to the Monster.

Either way, you've got a couple of nice cards.

Frank

 

[Soxfan33]

Hey everyone!

Thanks for the great feedback and your votes! It was neat to see what people look for in a card, and which card they would pick.

I will be keeping the one on the right. The one on the left is now going up for trade.

Thanks again,
John