Matt, to try to wrap this up, I looked up BV in the annual Beckett almanac. Total BV of this proposed trade is $35.50 for each of us. Check if you still have all the cards I can use from you, and if you need all the cards I listed. You can post if good. Thanks, Rob.
Guerrero Sr.: 7 cards, BV $18
2005 Leaf Limited 8 Vladimir Guerrero #647/699 $6
2006 Flair Showcase 18 Guerrero $2
2006 Topps 2K All-Stars #7 Vladimir Guerrero $4
2007 Fleer Perfect 10 Guerrero $2.50
2007 SP Rookie Edition 73 Guerrero $.75
2009 Sweet Spot 98 Guerrero $1.50
2010 Topps Chrome 39 Guerrero $1.25
Randy Johnson: 11 cards, BV $14
1997 Upper Deck 72 Randy Johnson SF .50
1999 Stadium Club 328 Randy Johnson TR .75
2001 Fleer Focus 64 Randy Johnson .75
2001 Upper Deck Victory 348 Randy Johnson .50
2002 Finest 3 Randy Johnson $1.25
2002 UD Authentics 118 Randy Johnson $1.25
2003 Upper Deck Vintage 65 Randy Johnson .75
2004 Donruss Classics Membership M-22 Randy Johnson #1453/2499 $2.50
2004 Topps Hobby Masters #14 Randy Johnson $2.50
2005 Topps Own the Game #29 Randy Johnson $2.50
2006 Bowman #162 Randy Johnson .75
Jim Thome: 3 cards, BV $3.50
2006 Topps Trading Places #JT Jim Thome $2.50
2006 Topps Allen and Ginter #14 Jim Thome .60
2012 Topps Update #US152 Jim Thome .40
In return for the above, I can use these cards from your "Super Trade" Google page:
1998 Topps Teck 21 Roger Clemens $3
1999 Topps Chrome Lords of the Diamond LD14 Mike Piazza $10
2008 Stadium Club First Day Issue Unnumbered (serial) 63 Kevin Youkilis $2
2011 Topps Diamond Duos DD-BY Wade Boggs Kevin Youkilis $1
2012 Topps Opening Day Blue 1479/2011 10 Joey Votto $6
2013 Bowman Chrome Top Prospects TP-14 Max Fried $2
2017 Topps '87 Topps 87-135 Sandy Koufax $2
2017 Topps First Pitch FP-1 William Shatner Red Sox $1.50
1989 Topps Tiffany 200 George Brett $8