Gary, here's at least a good base to work with given the 2016 BVs you provided. I'm giving you to make up for the Zimmermann/Abreu that you are giving up to get the Ruth/Upton in the AU + GU stuff...
FOR APPLEGATE
2013 Topps Wal-Mart Blue Border: 350 (A. Pujols), 357 (J. Francisco), 361 (E. Kratz), 383 (M. Harrison), 387 (J. Segura), 461 (D. Pomeranz), 514 (J. Papelbon), 515 (B. Roberts), 519 (Z. Greinke), 526 (T. Flowers), 531 (C. Gentry), 545 (A. Presley), 552 (F. Cervelli), 555 (J. Hanrahan), 573 (I. Stewart), 600 (M. Rivera), 608 (R. Nolasco), 655 (S. Perez) = $19.50
2013 Topps U&H Emerald: 7 (Y. Cespedes HRD), 10 (K. Youkilis), 48 (V. Worley), 73 (B. Posey AS), 136 (T. Hafner*), 170 (M. Tejada), 206 (R. Brignac), 310 (B. Logan) = $10.50 (Hafner has a bad corner from the hanger pack it was in, so it's free to you)
2013 Topps U&H Wal-Mart Blue Border: 7 (Y. Cespedes HRD), 71 (C. Asche RC) = $3.00
2014 Topps U&H Wal-Mart Blue Border: 97 (S. Perez AS), 295 (G. Holland AS) = $2.25
2015 Topps U&H: 3 (T. Wilson RC), 8 (A. Claudio RC), 10 (B. Parnell), 49 (M. Canha RC), 60 (B. Pinder RC), 70 (V. Worley), 98 (J. Fields), 122 (M. Byrd), 140 (M. Melancon AS), 144 (D. DeShields Jr. RC), 164 (J. Giavotella), 172 (A. Gonzalez AS), 179 (A. Liberatore RC), 183 (J. Turner), 187 (J. Donaldson/J. Bautista/D. Travis CC), 188 (J. deGrom/M. Harvey CC), 191 (E. Hosmer/M. Moustakas/K. Morales CC), 202 (M. Machado HRD), 207 (C. Young), 215 (J. Papelbon), 216 (C. Peguero), 222 (A. Caminero), 225 (K. Kela RC), 232 (H. Robles RC), 238 (A.J. Cole RC), 263 (P. Strop), 280 (M. Bolsinger FS), 296 (J.B. Shuck), 313 (J. Urena RC), 324 (C. Rodon RC), 348 (J. Broxton), 361 (L. Hawkins), 368 (A. Chapman AS) = $13.40
2016 Topps MLB Debut Medallions: B. Ruth, J. Upton = $20.00
TOTAL $68.65
-------------------------------------
FOR TIGSFAN
2009 Topps: 30 (K. Griffey Jr.) $2.00
2011 Topps: 316 (C. Young), 586 (C. Lee), 635 (J. Heyward) = $1.40
2011 Topps U&H: 15 (A. Heilman), 61 (N. Masset), 94 (R. Vogelsong), 110 (E. Renteria), 124 (X. Paul), 139 (R. Soriano), 148 (A. Presley), 166 (D. Ortiz), 291 (A. McCutchen) = $3.60
2012 Topps Golden Moments Autographs: J. Zimmermann $15.00
2013 Topps Update: 22 (C. Beltran AS) $.50
2014 Topps Chrome Update All-Star Stitches: J. Abreu $25.00
2015 Topps U&H Pride & Perseverance: 7 (J. Eisenrich) $1.00
2015 Topps Chrome Update: 291 (E. Butler FS) $1.25
2016 Topps S1: 5 (K. Seager), 12 (N. Arenado), 26 (C. Davis/M. Trout/N. Cruz LL), 32 (Z. Greinke), 33 (E. Volquez), 40 (J. Gyorko), 41 (J. Harrison), 53 (G. Springer), 60 (S. Miller), 61 (J. Cueto), 69 (A. Sanchez), 77 (C. Buchholz), 102 (D. Fister), 107 (K. Siegrist), 115 (A. Harang), 124 (M. Upton Jr.), 136 (M. Cuddyer), 148 (Y. Solarte), 149 (C. Bettis), 152 (K. Lohse), 155 (NY Yankees), 156 (C. Maybin), 163 (J. Benoit), 175 (M. Machado), 177 (G. Blanco), 192 (J. Jaso), 263 (J. Pederson), 289 (N. Hundley), 320 (J. Peavy), 328 (A. DeSclafani), 338 (P. Goldschmidt/D. Gordon/B. Harper LL), 342 (J. Werth), 343 (D. Hutchison), 345 (Y. Alonso), 351 (C. Utley) = $17.40
TOTAL: $67.15