12/20 - 4 Successes and 1 Failure

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.


Aug 31, 2009
Reaction score
Holly Springs, NC
Hey Everyone -

I got 4 successes and 1 Failure in today....

Keith Byars - NFL - 1986-1998
6654 North West 23rd Terrace
Boca Raton, FL 33496

2 of 2 CICs in 108 days

Tim Kerr - NHL - 1980-1993
335 Tom Brown Road
Moorestown, NJ 08057

5 of 6 (2 CICs and 3 Cards) in 6 days (Kept 1 Card - I offered him to keep any of the cards he wanted)

Fred Van Dusen - MLB - 1955
331 Gillette Drive
Franklin, TN 37069

3 of 3 (2 CICs and 1 QA) in 9 days

Here are his answers to the Questions I asked:
Favorite Player Growing Up? Willie Mays
Favorite Stadium to Play in? Connie Mack Stadium
Favorite Teammates? Curt Simmons & Wally Moses

Carlos Silva - MLB - 2002 to Present
c/o Chicago Cubs
Wrigley Field
1060 West Addison
Chicago, IL 60613

1 of 3 (Sent 1 CIC and 2 Cards) (Returned a 09 Topps) in 147 days

And the Failure..

Alan Knicely - MLB - 1979-1986
PO Box 433
Dayton, VA 22821

Sent 2 CICs on 10/28/09, returned both today unsigned, with a note on my letter saying "Sorry, don't autograph Index Cards."

Even though Knicely didn't sign the CICs, it was nice getting them back because I mostly send CICs and I feel that alot of them don't get returned because players dont sign Index Cards. At least he took the time to let me know that. Oh well.

Thanks for looking!

Scobes :D