well 3 5 and 6 is going to be a pretty penny....get a local hometown boy. oregon has some players from there. alot more fun and prob get them at a fraction of what u are going to pay for those listed....
I would go with Lou Gehrig I can put a big dent in your PC if you do, LOL. Of what you listed, I guess it depends on which sport you wish to focus on. I would got with King Felix as a baseball guy and there have been some good points on him in the thread already.
I say ignore whoever any of us put in this thread and pick someone you can really connect with. If not, you will not really enjoy being a "Player Collector". It is different than any other kind of collecting in my opinion.
I have thought about adding Jerome Walton and Dwight Smith to my Andre Dawson collection, but nothing else keeps me interested like Dawson does.
Who do you like the most? Is there a reason why you chose those players?
The players I collect for my PC is any (whether I have it or not) card of Rich Gedman, Gorman Thomas and Kent Hrbek. The reason why I collect them is that as a kid a looked at them and thought that they did not look like athletes, yet they were. They gave me the impression that anyone, with enough hard work, could grow up and play baseball at the highest level.