20 Questions contest - Round 5 LIVE...

[mrknicks]

Is it a base card?

 

[cmcjr99]

CMCJR99: great contest, really enjoy it. Regarding Question #18: with all the clues given up to that point, I had it narrowed down to Vizquel or Jose Bautista. Neither Carlos Pena nor Zobrist had cards with NL teams between 2000-2009, so they weren't an option. At that point, I believed Vizquel or Bautista was the key question to ask. Thanks, and looking forward to the next one.


Luis

ya got me on pena whose first card picturing him with the cubs was a single insert in 2010 topps heritage which falls just a bit outside the 2000-2008 window...

as for zobrist , he does in fact have plenty cards featuring him as an astro , but when my analysis left him in as a possibility i overlooked the fact that none of them were topps products....

 

[cmcjr99]

i'll start

is it a baseball card?

no

Is it a base card?

no


round 4 -
prize pool for this round :
1987 topps barry bonds rookie
1999 topps donovan mcnabb rookie

Q1 - mj23bullsfan - baseball ? no
Q2 - mrknicks - base card ? no

 

[Dalberov]

Is it a football card?

 

[cmcjr99]

Is it a football card?

yes


round 4 -
prize pool for this round :
1987 topps barry bonds rookie
1999 topps donovan mcnabb rookie

Q1 - mj23bullsfan - baseball card ? no
Q2 - mrknicks - base card ? no
Q3 - Dalberov - football card ? yes

 

[plopowitz]

Is it an offensive player??

 

[cincikid]

Is it an AFC player?

Thanks for the contest.

David

 

[dragonslayer913]

Is this player a Quarterback ?

 

[baseball24]

Card made after 2000?

 

[mm1sub]

Was it made after 2005?

 

[cmcjr99]

Is it an offensive player??

yes

Is it an AFC player?
Thanks for the contest.
David

yes

Is this player a Quarterback ?

yes

Card made after 2000?

no

Was it made after 2005?

i almost feel bad answering this one considering the previous question....

no


round 4 -
prize pool for this round :
1987 topps barry bonds rookie
1999 topps donovan mcnabb rookie

Q1 - mj23bullsfan - baseball card ? no
Q2 - mrknicks - base card ? no
Q3 - Dalberov - football card ? yes
Q4 - plopowitz - offensive player ? yes
Q5 - cincikid - AFC player ? yes
Q6 - dragonslayer913 - QB ? yes
Q7 - baseball24 - made after 2000 ? no
Q8 - mm1sub - made after 2005 ? no

 

[chief wahoo]

Was he a starting QB in a Super Bowl?

 

[grapler135s]

Was the card made after 1990?

 

[cmcjr99]

Was he a starting QB in a Super Bowl?

yes

Was the card made after 1990?

yes

round 4 -
prize pool for this round :
1987 topps barry bonds rookie
1999 topps donovan mcnabb rookie

Q1 - mj23bullsfan - baseball card ? no
Q2 - mrknicks - base card ? no
Q3 - Dalberov - football card ? yes
Q4 - plopowitz - offensive player ? yes
Q5 - cincikid - AFC player ? yes
Q6 - dragonslayer913 - QB ? yes
Q7 - baseball24 - made after 2000 ? no
Q8 - mm1sub - made after 2005 ? no
Q9 - chief wahoo - starting qb in super bowl ? yes
Q10 - grapler135s - made after 1990 ? yes

 

[mintman2]

hof player ?

 

[cmcjr99]

hof player ?

yes

round 4 -
prize pool for this round :
1987 topps barry bonds rookie
1999 topps donovan mcnabb rookie

Q1 - mj23bullsfan - baseball card ? no
Q2 - mrknicks - base card ? no
Q3 - Dalberov - football card ? yes
Q4 - plopowitz - offensive player ? yes
Q5 - cincikid - AFC player ? yes
Q6 - dragonslayer913 - QB ? yes
Q7 - baseball24 - made after 2000 ? no
Q8 - mm1sub - made after 2005 ? no
Q9 - chief wahoo - starting qb in super bowl ? yes
Q10 - grapler135s - made after 1990 ? yes
Q11 - mintman2 - HOFer ? yes


also , remember that when submitting a GUESS i need the following : year , brand , set , card number , and player name (ie , 1979 topps 500 terry bradshaw or 1992 fleer all-stars 16 barry larkin)

 

[mintman2]

For what it's worth, a couple suggestions.......

#1 Start a new thread for each round.

#2 Don't count questions like Q8 as it was already answered. It's hard enough narrowing a specific card without losing questions to repeats.

Edit: WOW, that was fast !

 

[cmcjr99]

For what it's worth, a couple suggestions.......

#1 Start a new thread for each round.

#2 Don't count questions like Q8 as it was already answered. It's hard enough narrowing a specific card without losing questions to repeats.

Edit: WOW, that was fast !

pretty much figured that it would just be easier to track one thread....

as for your 2nd point , that's why i had THIS in the rules in the first post :

4 - when a question is posted by an eligible member , please WAIT for my reply before posting another question

most people seemed to ignore it so i pretty much chose from two options : answer EVERY eligible question as soon as i see it (even if it's a pointless question) or completely ignore all but the first question posted each time i come back to answer one....i chose the former for good or bad...

 

[mj23bullsfan]

when this player started in the super bowl, were the primary colors of his teams uniform red, white and blue?

 

[cmcjr99]

when this player started in the super bowl, were the primary colors of his teams uniform red, white and blue?

new rule - after round 1's controversy over what constitutes a "team color" and what is an "actual color" vs a "shade of color" , i won't answer team color questions anymore.....just too many gray areas here IMO....